Jeremy retorts that RAID is alive and well in the real world:

Kevin Burton wrote a sort-of-reply to my call for action in getting LSI to open source their CLI tool for the LSI MegaRAID SAS aka Dell PERC 5/i, where he asserted that ?RAID is dying?. I?d like to assert otherwise. In my world, RAID is quite alive and well. Why?

I should note that I said:

I?d like to assert that in 3-5 years RAID will be a thing of the past.

I’m not saying it’s dead now - but I do think it’s dying.

RAID is cheap. Contrary to popular opinion, RAID isn?t really that expensive. The controller is cheap (only $299 for Dell?s PERC 5/i, with BBWC, if you pay full retail).

… that’s the price of one HDD. You’ve just lost some IO there. Granted this isn’t a major issue but it all ads …

Kevin Burton wrote a sort-of-reply to my call for action in getting LSI to open source their CLI tool for the LSI MegaRAID SAS aka Dell PERC 5/i, where he asserted that “RAID is dying”. I’d like to assert otherwise. In my world, RAID is quite alive and well. Why?

• RAID is cheap. Contrary to popular opinion, RAID isn’t really that expensive. The controller is cheap (only $299 for Dell’s PERC 5/i, with BBWC, if you pay full retail). The “2x” disk usage in RAID 10 is really quite debatable, since those disks aren’t just wasting space, they are also improving read (and subsequently write) performance.
• Latency. The battery-backed write …

In an effort to reduce the number of open tabs I have in Firefox, I have some rather interesting MySQL-related resources that I think the rest of Planet MySQL will quite enjoy.

• Linbit (the makers of DRBD) and MySQL are in a partnership now, and Irwan Jamaluddin, a systems adminstrator at one of the only Linux support companies in Malaysia, has recently blogged about his journey with DRBD and MySQL. The operating system base is RHEL 5, and there is a step-by-step guide on how he got it working. From what I gather, its a cut-n-paste tutorial, not something I’ve verified, but I’m sure I’ll refer to it when I want to play with DRBD.
• MySQL Basics in Pictures. Granted they’ve used an odd version of Linux for the basis of the tutorial, but that doesn’t affect the quality of the …

Jan Kneschke works for the MySQL Development Team and is the author of the very popular lighttpd web server. I recently had the opportunity to ask him a few questions about himself and his work.

In our last installment, we looked at how to write data into a storage engine, now lets look at updating it.

To update data you need to first know that it exists. To do this MySQL reads the rows that need to be updated, either by index or scan read. Since we have already spoken on scan reads, we are going to look at updates that occur that need to scan the entire table. MySQL will start up a read and do the folllowing:

rnd_init()
rnd_next()
rnd_next()
rnd_next()
update_row()
rnd_next()
rnd_next()
rnd_end()

In the above example, MySQL find four rows in the table. The third row is matched for an update. The engine writer doesn't have to do to the predicate test themselves (aka ... UPDAT E A SET b=5 WHERE a=3, the engine writer doesn't need to worry about matching the a=3). The …

I recently saw the Planet MySQL post Five months with MySQL Cluster by Brian Moon.

Thought I’d add my 5 cents worth (Australian’s don’t have 1 cent coins any more to make 2 cents worth)

Firstly, it’s great you wrote about your experiences in moving to MySQL Cluster. I think more people should.

Joins

“We used a lot of joins. We learned (later) that joins in the cluster are not a good idea.”

MySQL Cluster’s number one strength is Primary Key Lookups, it’s very good you learned that joins (especially say 5-6-7 table joins) are not a good idea, it is not a strength, and certainly not scalable to thousands of queries per second.

Rewrite

“We rewrote our application (basically, our public web site) to use …

So, the whole world changed at dealnews when Yahoo! linked us. We realized that our current infrastructure was not scaling very well. We had to make a change.

The Problem

Even though we were using all sorts of cool techniques, the server architecture was really still just a bunch of web servers all serving the same content. In addition to that, our existing systems as the time used a pull method. When a request came in, memcache was checked, if the data was not there, it was fetched from our main MySQL server. So, when there is no data in the cache or when it expires, this was very bad. Like when Yahoo! hit us. Some cache item would expire and 60,000 users would hit a page and each page would try and create the cache item.

The Solution

I …

A short post to draw your attention to this article by Kevin Burton titled “MySQL and the Death of Raid”. Although it’s written from the MySQL point of view, he does bring up some interesting points on the advantages of what he calls a “RAISe” or Redundant Array of Independent Servers” architecture (actually I coined [...]

Mohd Irwan Jamaluddin, RHCE from Malaysia, writes about his experience with DRBD and MySQL on RHEL 5 after some mixed emotions with MySQL Cluster and Continuent uni/cluster. I always love to read from happy sysadmins out there. What I like to hear best, in terms of adapting your application for an HA environment, is this:

MySQL configuration: Nothing much to talk about MySQL, I’m just using default packages (and default configurations) from RHEL 5.

Now, for those who don’t like the idea of compiling Heartbeat from source, you can of course also use Red Hat’s own cluster manager with DRBD. And then if you’re on MySQL Enterprise, there’s no need to compile even DRBD, as you get the binary RPMs for that as well.
…

Mårten responded right away to my challenge . (thank you Mårten), his responses below:

1) Team

A superb team is a must in all start-ups. The special thing with open source startups is that they may have a history as an open source *project* before becoming a commercial business. The team must understand how to master this evolutionary transition.

2) Innovation

It’s not enough to be less expensive, or faster, or the same as others but open source. There has to be a genuine, value-adding innovation that users and customers get a new benefit from.

3) Participation

The strength of open source lies in massive participation by users worldwide. It takes special dedication and skill to build an
architecture of participation.

-1) Open source as the silver …