I have never been that interested in strict definitions of concepts and this never-ending discussion of what is and isn't open source is an interesting philosophical argument but not an entirely practical one.
There is no question that the GPL offers many benefits to companies/people who create products and release them under that license. But it's not for everyone, and there is often a necessary evolution (as Matt and SOG note) where the benefit of adoption under MPL or Apache or whatever are potentially more important than what the GPL affords.
Matt is excited about going to GPL and I back Alfresco's choice 100%. I think it makes sense for the business and where their product lives in the enterprise stack. But GPL doesn't make sense for everything (not that I think Matt believes it does, but I have had a number of people …
[Read more]