Working on query optimizer bugs can be a rather frustrating experience. First, as soon as some query doesn't run as fast it theoretically could people will consider it a bug. On one hand that's great, you get a constant stream of user input, but on the other hand you end up with a whole pile of "bugs" which you can't hope to finish.
What's more frustrating is that even if you manage to create a fix for an optimizer bug, there are chances it won't be allowed into next GA (currently 5.0.70) or approaching-GA (currently 5.1.30) release (GA is our term for "stable" or "release").
The reason behind this is that most optimizer bugfixes cause the optimizer to pick different query plans, and there's no way to guarantee that the fix will be a change for the better for absolutely everyone. Experience shows that it is possible to have a query that hits two optimizer bugs/deficiencies at once in such a way that they cancel each other out, and …[Read more]