I updated the innotsim client to include a new custom mutex
from InnoDB in MySQL 5.7. This is called TTASFutexMutex in the source. I also fixed a
bug in innotsim - the benchmark timer was started too soon so
these results are more accurate than the original post.
The original post has much more detail on the tests. In the graphs below, TTASFutexMutex has the label inno futex and the old-style custom mutex that uses a sync array has the label inno syncarray. My updated conclusions are:
- TTASFutexMutex is worse than pthread default when the lock hold duration is short but gets better as the lock hold duration is increased. I wonder if this conclusion will hold across Linux releases.
- The InnoDB mutex that uses a sync array continues to show its dark side with high concurrency but is pretty good with lower concurrency.
- I am not sure that pthread adaptive should be used at all. It is frequently worse, occasionally much worse and in the base case not much better than pthread default. But I am using glibc 2.12 which was released in 2010. I don't know yet whether my conclusions hold for a recent glibc release. Alas, this appears to be widely used by both InnoDB and non-InnoDB code in mysqld (grep for MY_MUTEX_INIT_FAST). I think more benchmark results are required to figure this out. It might help to have an option in my.cnf to prevent it from being used.